Best Pike Spoons: 5 Picks for Open Water and Weeds
Few lures have caught as many northern pike as a simple wobbling spoon. A spoon casts far, covers water fast,...
Few lures have caught as many northern pike as a simple wobbling spoon. A spoon casts far, covers water fast, flashes like a wounded baitfish, and can be fished over weeds, along drop-offs, or trolled. The right pike spoon depends mostly on cover: open water calls for a classic treble-hook spoon, and weed beds call for a weedless design.
This guide compares five spoons for pike from Dardevle, Johnson, Rapala, Williams, and Huskie. We compared weight, length, hook setup, finish, and what each maker publishes about action. For smaller spoons for trout, see our trout spoons guide.
Our Top Picks
| Best for | Product | FH Score About FH ScoreThe FH Score is our editorial rating from 0 to 10, based on published specs, materials, warranty and value. It is not based on Amazon ratings and is never influenced by commissions. Learn more › | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best overall |
Dardevle Spoon (1 oz)
|
8.2/10 | Check Price |
| Best for weeds |
Johnson Silver Minnow (1 1/8 oz)
|
7.9/10 | Check Price |
| Best weedless profile |
Rapala Minnow Spoon (RMS-10)
|
7.6/10 | Check Price |
| Most flash |
Williams Wabler W60 (3/4 oz)
|
7.6/10 | Check Price |
| Best for deep water |
Huskie Junior Spoon (2 oz)
|
7.1/10 | Check Price |
The Picks in Detail
Dardevle Spoon (1 oz)
Why it made the list: The Dardevle dates back to Lou Eppinger’s 1906 design, and Eppinger includes the 1 oz size in its own Pike Pack. At 3 5/8 inches long and 1 1/4 inches wide, it casts far on medium-heavy gear and wobbles at slow and moderate speeds. Eppinger tags it for northern pike, bass, and walleye and sells it with nickel, brass, or copper backs.
Key specs: 1 oz; 3 5/8 x 1 1/4 in; treble hook; nickel, brass, or copper back; many front colors, including the classic red and white. The linked listing is black and white stripe with a nickel back. A weedless 1 oz version is also sold.
Skip it if: you fish thick weed beds or lily pads. Use the Johnson Silver Minnow or Rapala Minnow Spoon.
Pros
- Proven pike size and shape
- Wide choice of colors and backs
- Low cost to replace
Cons
- Treble hook snags in weeds
- Can twist line without a swivel
Johnson Silver Minnow (1 1/8 oz)
Why it made the list: The Silver Minnow has a single hook protected by a metal weed guard, so you can drag it over and through cabbage, coontail, and pads where pike ambush prey. Johnson designed its 35-degree wobble to rock without rolling, which reduces line twist, and plates the spoon in real silver or 24K gold for flash.
Key specs: 1 1/8 oz; 3 3/4 in; single hook with metal weed guard; brass blade plated in silver or 24K gold; 35-degree wobble; cast, troll, or jig.
Skip it if: you fish open water with few weeds. A treble-hook spoon like the Dardevle hooks more fish.
Pros
- Fishes through weeds and slop
- Designed not to twist line
- Heavy enough for long casts
Cons
- Weed guard can cost some hookups
- Single hook only
Rapala Minnow Spoon (RMS-10)
Why it made the list: The Rapala Minnow Spoon is a weedless spoon with a baitfish-shaped body. The 10 cm size weighs 32 grams (about 1 1/8 oz) and Rapala lists it for casting and trolling, with pike among its target species. It is a good alternative to the Silver Minnow with different color patterns.
Key specs: 10 cm (about 4 in); 32 g; weedless single hook; casting or trolling; listed for pike, redfish, snook, and other species.
Skip it if: you want maximum wobble in open water. A wide classic spoon like the Dardevle moves more.
Pros
- Weedless and realistic shape
- Good casting weight
- Works in fresh and salt water
Cons
- Few action details published
- Color stock on the listing varies
Williams Wabler W60 (3/4 oz)
Why it made the list: Williams stamps its spoons from brass and plates them with genuine silver and 24K gold. The Wabler W60 is a 3 1/4 inch, 3/4 oz spoon with a wrinkled finish that scatters light, a good choice in clear water and bright sun. It is made in Canada, where pike fishing is a major draw.
Key specs: 3/4 oz; 3 1/4 in; Silver and Gold Nu-Wrinkle finish (linked listing); treble hook; made in Canada.
Skip it if: you need to reach deep water or cast into wind. The 1 oz Dardevle or 2 oz Huskie Junior is heavier.
Pros
- Real silver and gold plating
- Wrinkled finish adds flash
- Lighter weight for shallow water
Cons
- Lighter spoon does not cast as far
- Treble hook snags in weeds
Huskie Junior Spoon (2 oz)
Why it made the list: Late in the season, big pike often move deeper. The 2 oz Huskie Junior, from the same maker as the Dardevle, sinks fast and casts very far, and its hammered nickel finish adds flash. It can also be trolled.
Key specs: 2 oz; hammered nickel finish; nickel-plated back; casting or trolling; fresh or salt water.
Skip it if: you fish shallow weedy bays in spring. Use a 3/4 to 1 oz spoon.
Pros
- Reaches deep water quickly
- Very long casts
- Large profile for big pike
Cons
- Needs heavy rod and line
- Too heavy for shallow bays
Pike Spoons Compared
| Spoon | Weight | Length | Hook | Weedless |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dardevle | 1 oz | 3 5/8 in | Treble | No (weedless version sold) |
| Johnson Silver Minnow | 1 1/8 oz | 3 3/4 in | Single | Yes |
| Rapala Minnow Spoon | 32 g | 10 cm | Single | Yes |
| Williams Wabler W60 | 3/4 oz | 3 1/4 in | Treble | No |
| Huskie Junior | 2 oz | Not stated | Not stated | No |
How We Picked
We did not fish these spoons for this guide. We researched each one and compared the specifications published by the makers on their websites and Amazon listings. Our criteria:
- Size and weight suited to pike.
- Hook setup: treble for open water, weedless for cover.
- Finish and flash.
- Action as described by the maker.
- Value.
The FH Score in each product box is our editorial rating, built from five weighted criteria: performance for the job, build quality, versatility, warranty and value. Lures have no meaningful warranty, so every spoon gets the same neutral warranty score. It is not based on Amazon ratings. See how it works on our How We Review page.
How to Fish Spoons for Pike
Always use a leader
Pike teeth cut monofilament and braid. Use a wire, titanium, or heavy fluorocarbon leader of about 12 inches or more, with a ball-bearing swivel to reduce line twist.
Match the spoon to cover
Cast treble-hook spoons along weed edges, points, and open flats. Switch to weedless spoons over the top of submerged weeds and through pads.
Vary the retrieve
Try a steady retrieve first, then add pauses so the spoon flutters down. Many strikes come as the spoon falls.
Color
Red and white, five of diamonds, silver, and gold are classic pike choices. Bright and dark patterns stand out in stained water; plain metal finishes work well in clear water.
Handle pike safely
Carry long-nose pliers or a hook remover, and a jaw spreader if you fish treble hooks. See our fishing pliers guide.
Related Guides
- Best Trout Spoons
- Best Musky Reels
- Best Snakehead Lures
- Best Spinnerbaits
- Best Rod for Muskie Fishing
- Fluorocarbon Leader for Pike
- Best Pike Lures
- Best Pickerel Lures
- Best Spoons for Walleye
- Best Weedless Pike Lures
- Best Pike Spinners
See more in our Spoons and Inline Spinners section.
FAQ
What size spoon is best for pike?
Most anglers use 3/4 to 1 oz spoons around 3 to 4 inches long. Use heavier spoons for deep water and long casts.
Do I need a wire leader for pike spoons?
Yes, or a heavy fluorocarbon or titanium leader. Pike can bite through regular line.
What color spoon do pike like?
Red and white is the classic, but silver, gold, and bright patterns all work. Change colors with water clarity and light.
Final Thoughts
The 1 oz Dardevle is our top pick for its proven size and action. Choose the Johnson Silver Minnow for weeds, the Rapala Minnow Spoon for a weedless baitfish shape, the Williams Wabler for maximum flash in clear water, and the 2 oz Huskie Junior for deep water and long casts.
