Best Conventional Fishing Reels: 5 Picks for Bottom and Offshore
A conventional reel sits on top of the rod and pays line straight off a revolving spool. That design gives...
A conventional reel sits on top of the rod and pays line straight off a revolving spool. That design gives it more line capacity, more cranking power, and a stronger drag than a spinning reel of similar weight, which is why it is the standard choice for bottom fishing, drifting baits, jigging, and big fish from boats, piers, and the surf.
This guide compares five conventional reels from PENN, Shimano, Daiwa, and Avet, from a simple level wind for bottom fishing to a machined lever drag reel. We compared drag, gear ratio, line capacity, frame material, and warranty from what each maker publishes. If you mainly troll, see our trolling reels guide, which covers line counter and two-speed models.
Our Top Picks
| Best for | Product | FH Score About FH ScoreThe FH Score is our editorial rating from 0 to 10, based on published specs, materials, warranty and value. It is not based on Amazon ratings and is never influenced by commissions. Learn more › | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best overall |
PENN Squall II Star Drag
|
7.5/10 | Check Price |
| Best for heavy bottom fishing |
Shimano Torium 50HGA
|
7.8/10 | Check Price |
| Best for jigging with braid |
Daiwa Saltist SD 35
|
7.3/10 | Check Price |
| Best compact lever drag |
Avet SX 5.3 G2 Lever Drag
|
7.2/10 | Check Price |
| Best budget level wind |
PENN General Purpose Level Wind
|
6.3/10 | Check Price |
The Picks in Detail
PENN Squall II Star Drag
Why it made the list: The Squall II covers the most common conventional jobs at a moderate cost: bottom fishing, drifting live bait, and light offshore work. PENN uses a graphite frame and sideplates, a marine-grade bronze main gear, a stainless pinion, and its Versa-Drag system with HT-100 washers. The 12 and 15 sizes are rated for 20 lb of max drag and the 30 and 40 sizes for 25 lb, with a 6+1 shielded stainless bearing system. The size 40 holds 420 yards of 30 lb mono.
Key specs: Sizes 12, 15, 30, 40 (choose on the listing); 20 to 25 lb max drag by size; 6+1 bearings; graphite frame and sideplates; bronze main gear; Live Spindle free-floating spool; PENN 1-year limited warranty.
Skip it if: you fish deep water for big grouper or amberjack. The Shimano Torium 50 has more drag and capacity.
Pros
- Strong drag for the price and size
- Four sizes cover inshore to light offshore
- Free-floating spool helps with casting
Cons
- Graphite frame flexes more than aluminum under heavy loads
- No level wind, so you guide the line with your thumb
Shimano Torium 50HGA
Why it made the list: The Torium 50HG is the heavy hitter here. Shimano rates it for 31 lb of max drag with a 5.1:1 gear ratio, and its spool holds 470 yards of 50 lb mono or 1,600 yards of 50 lb PowerPro braid. That capacity and drag suit deep-water bottom fishing and big offshore fish. Shimano builds it on a rigid HAGANE body with a Cross Carbon drag.
Key specs: 5.1:1 gear ratio; 31 lb max drag; 4+1 bearings; 29.8 oz; mono 470/50, 370/60, 270/80 (yd/lb); PowerPro 1,600/50, 1,150/65, 950/80; HAGANE body; Cross Carbon drag.
Skip it if: you fish piers, bays, or nearshore reefs. The PENN Squall II is lighter and cheaper for those jobs.
Pros
- Most drag and capacity in this guide
- Rigid body for heavy loads
- High-speed gear picks up slack line quickly
Cons
- Heavy at almost 30 oz, tiring for casting or all-day holding
- Too big for inshore or pier fishing
- Warranty terms not found on Shimano’s product page
Daiwa Saltist SD 35
Why it made the list: Daiwa’s current Saltist SD star drag reels use an aluminum frame and sideplate with Daiwa’s ATD carbon fiber drag, which is designed to start smoothly under load. The SLTSD35 listing gives a 6.4:1 gear ratio and 4 corrosion-resistant ball bearings plus a roller bearing. A fast retrieve on a stiff aluminum frame suits vertical jigging and working braid in deep water.
Key specs: Size 35; 6.4:1 gear ratio (per listing); 4CRBB + 1 roller bearing; aluminum frame and sideplate; ATD carbon fiber drag. Max drag and line capacity: not stated on the pages we found, check the listing.
Skip it if: you want published, easy-to-compare specs before you buy. The Shimano Torium lists full drag and capacity numbers.
Pros
- Aluminum frame resists flex
- Fast gear ratio for jigging
- Daiwa also sells a dedicated jigging version
Cons
- Drag and capacity figures were hard to confirm
- Costs more than the PENN Squall II
Avet SX 5.3 G2 Lever Drag
Why it made the list: A lever drag lets you preset a strike setting and move between drag levels without guessing, which many anglers prefer for live baiting and fighting larger fish. The SX 5.3 is Avet’s small lever drag reel, machined from 6061-T6 marine-grade aluminum with stainless components and an anodized finish. Retailer spec tables list a 5.3:1 gear ratio and about 20 lb of full drag for the G2 version.
Key specs: Lever drag; 5.3:1 gear ratio; machined 6061-T6 aluminum; anodized finish. Strike drag and braid capacity differ between retailer listings, so check the current spec table.
Skip it if: you are new to conventional reels or on a budget. A star drag like the PENN Squall II is simpler and costs less.
Pros
- Lever drag with repeatable settings
- Machined aluminum build in a compact size
- Small enough for inshore and nearshore rods
Cons
- Highest cost per pound of drag here
- Spec figures vary between sellers
- Small spool limits heavy-line capacity
PENN General Purpose Level Wind
Why it made the list: The General Purpose is a classic, simple level wind reel for pier, party boat, and bottom fishing. The level wind lays line evenly across the spool for you, which helps beginners avoid line piling up on one side. PENN lists a machined aluminum spool, Bakelite sideplates, a brass main gear, a 3.2:1 gear ratio, and an HT-100 star drag with 10 lb of max drag.
Key specs: 3.2:1 gear ratio; 19 in of line per crank; 2 ball bearings; 10 lb max drag; mono 360/17, 290/20, 190/30 (yd/lb); braid 575/30, 400/50, 330/65; right hand; stainless level wind; PENN 1-year limited warranty.
Skip it if: you jig or need to pick up line fast. The Daiwa Saltist SD has double the gear ratio.
Pros
- Level wind spreads line evenly
- Simple, long-running design
- Lowest cost of the group
Cons
- Slow 3.2:1 retrieve
- 10 lb max drag is light for big fish
- Right hand only
Conventional Reels Compared
| Reel | Drag type | Gear ratio | Max drag | Frame | Level wind |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PENN Squall II Star Drag | Star | By size | 20 to 25 lb | Graphite | No |
| Shimano Torium 50HGA | Star | 5.1:1 | 31 lb | HAGANE body | No |
| Daiwa Saltist SD 35 | Star | 6.4:1 | Not stated | Aluminum | No |
| Avet SX 5.3 G2 | Lever | 5.3:1 | About 20 lb (retailers) | Machined aluminum | No |
| PENN General Purpose | Star | 3.2:1 | 10 lb | Bakelite sideplates | Yes |
How We Picked
We did not fish these reels for this guide. We researched each one and compared the specifications published by the makers on their websites, warranty pages, and Amazon listings, plus retailer spec tables where the maker’s page was missing. Our criteria:
- Drag: max drag and drag material for the target fish.
- Line capacity for the depth and line you fish.
- Frame and gears: stiffness and corrosion resistance.
- Retrieve speed for bait, bottom, or jigging work.
- Warranty and value.
We left out reels whose listing did not show which size ships, and trolling reels with line counters, which have their own guide. The FH Score in each product box is our editorial rating, built from five weighted criteria: performance for the job, build quality, versatility, warranty and value. It is not based on Amazon ratings. See how it works on our How We Review page.
How to Choose a Conventional Reel
Star drag or lever drag
A star drag tightens with a star-shaped wheel by the handle. It is simple and costs less. A lever drag uses a lever with a preset strike position, so you can return to the same setting during a fight. Lever drags usually cost more.
Level wind or not
A level wind guides line evenly across the spool, which is easier for beginners. Reels without one cast farther and handle heavier line, but you lay the line with your thumb.
Size and capacity
Match capacity to the depth and the fish. Bay and pier fishing needs a few hundred yards of 20 to 30 lb line. Deep bottom fishing calls for a larger spool filled with braid. Braid lets a smaller reel hold much more line than mono of the same strength.
Gear ratio
Low ratios crank with more power for heavy sinkers and big fish. High ratios pick up line faster for jigging. See our saltwater braided line guide for spooling options.
Related Guides
- Best Trolling Reels
- Best Saltwater Fishing Reels
- Best Saltwater Fishing Rods
- Best Braided Fishing Line for Saltwater
- Best Tuna Lures
- Best Fishing Rods for Deep Sea Fishing
- Best Saltwater Casting Reels
See more in our Conventional Reels section.
FAQ
What is a conventional fishing reel?
A reel with a revolving spool that sits on top of the rod. It is built for heavier line and stronger drag than most baitcasters, mainly for saltwater fishing.
Is a conventional reel the same as a baitcaster?
They work the same way. Baitcasters are smaller, low-profile reels for casting lures. Conventional reels are larger and round, built for capacity and drag.
Can you cast a conventional reel?
Yes, but it takes practice to avoid backlash. Smaller reels with a free-floating spool or casting control, like the Squall II 15CS, are easier to cast.
Are conventional reels good for beginners?
For bottom fishing from a boat or pier, yes. A level wind model like the PENN General Purpose is the simplest place to start.
Final Thoughts
The PENN Squall II Star Drag is our top pick for an affordable conventional reel that covers bottom fishing and light offshore work. Choose the Shimano Torium 50HGA for deep water and big fish, the Daiwa Saltist SD for jigging with braid, the Avet SX 5.3 G2 for a compact lever drag, and the PENN General Purpose for a simple, low-cost level wind.
